In the MMA world, the major dream fight being talked about right now
is Anderson Silva versus Georges St. Pierre. I was completely on board
with this fight happening...three years ago. But some things have
happened since then that has made me change my mind. The first was that
it was pointed out that the risk-reward for each fighter is disproportionate.
GSP has more to gain than to lose and Silva has more to lose than to
gain. What shame does GSP have in losing to Silva? On the other hand,
what is there to gain from Silva beating a smaller fighter? Silva
beating GSP wouldn't be that impressive. The same even goes for GSP beating
Silva, after what happened at UFC 117 (where Chael Sonnen took, and held
down, Silva at will). Yes, there were questionable circumstances
surrounding the fight (Silva being injured, Sonnen on PEDs etc.), but
the fact remains that the novelty of seeing Silva dominated through
wrestling is gone. That's the problem with this fight. The outcome
will almost certainly resemble either GSP-Serra I (albeit more
legitimately) or Silva-Sonnen I (albeit more legitimately). It doesn't
have the unpredictable nature that a dream fight should have.
The
next thing that happened was UFC 128 and the beginning of Jon Jones'
ascension up the P4P rankings. Jones' victory over Shogun was the most
dominant title win I'd seen since that of one Anderson Silva. It was
this precise moment that the prospect of a Jones-Silva fight surpassed
Silva-GSP. Silva and Jones are two of the, if not the, best and most
creative strikers in the sport. This fight is not predictable.
Technically Jones could employ a Sonnen-like gameplan, but there's also
the possibility that something happens that's never been done before
(Jones getting picked apart or vice versa); something that's not
possible with GSP. Not to mention that, unlike GSP-Silva, the loser
doesn't take a big hit. If Jones were to lose, then it would be to the
greatest fighter of all-time. And if Silva were to lose, it would be to
a younger fighter just entering his prime (and could be on his way to
being the greatest of all-time). It's a win-win. Both fighters would
be helped by a win and not that hurt by a loss.
Not
only is Silva-Jones a more exciting, even, and unpredictable matchup,
but both fighters are in similar situations of not really having imminent contenders. Other than postponing a potential Dan Henderson-Jon Jones fight (which could've been avoided had the UFC just rescheduled
Henderson-Jones, instead of irrationally plugging in a completely
undeserving Chael Sonnen), neither division would
be held up by a super fight. That's not the case with the Welterweight
division. GSP has both Nick Diaz and Johnny Hendricks waiting in the wings (not to mention Rory MacDonald closing in on a title shot). In fact, I'd much rather see GSP fight Diaz over Silva. Diaz's boxing and Jiu-Jitsu make for a good stylistic matchup with GSP. Even if he couldn't beat GSP, he should at least be able to get a great fight out of him (much like Condit just did).
Thankfully, GSP-Diaz is exactly the direction the UFC is going in. The next step is moving on from the idea of GSP fighting Silva and switching to the true dream fight: Silva versus Jon Jones.
Saturday, December 15, 2012
Thursday, December 13, 2012
Who's up first?
When I broke down the AL MVP race, one of the things I mentioned was how RBIs are somewhat circumstantial. Being a good hitter doesn't automatically get you RBIs; you do need runners on base (obviously). In the same way, having runners on base could lead to RBIs, even if a player isn't hitting great. For a perfect example of this, look no further than Hunter Pence. Pence finished 14th in baseball with 104 RBIs, even though he only hit .253 (106th in the league). But that doesn't tell the full story. Because Pence was on two different teams, you can see the difference in production.
In Philly, Pence hit 59 RBIs in 398 at-bats. In San Francisco, he had 45 RBIs in 219 at-bats. In order to give a clearer comparison, let's look at how many RBIs he would have had if he had played a full year in each location. Pence was on pace for 630 at-bats in Philly and 594 at-bats in San Francisco. We'll just average the two and set the hypothetical number at 612 at-bats. Assuming he had 612 ABs, Pence was on pace for 91 RBIs in Philly and 126 RBIs in San Francisco. What's even crazier? Pence was hitting .271 in Philly and only .219 with the Giants. Using the same 612 ABs, that's the difference between finishing with 166 hits and 134. Pence would have 35 more RBIs, despite getting 32 less hits! If you can hit worse, yet drive in more runs, something tells me that who bats in front of you does make a pretty big difference.
In Philly, Pence hit 59 RBIs in 398 at-bats. In San Francisco, he had 45 RBIs in 219 at-bats. In order to give a clearer comparison, let's look at how many RBIs he would have had if he had played a full year in each location. Pence was on pace for 630 at-bats in Philly and 594 at-bats in San Francisco. We'll just average the two and set the hypothetical number at 612 at-bats. Assuming he had 612 ABs, Pence was on pace for 91 RBIs in Philly and 126 RBIs in San Francisco. What's even crazier? Pence was hitting .271 in Philly and only .219 with the Giants. Using the same 612 ABs, that's the difference between finishing with 166 hits and 134. Pence would have 35 more RBIs, despite getting 32 less hits! If you can hit worse, yet drive in more runs, something tells me that who bats in front of you does make a pretty big difference.
Monday, December 10, 2012
UFC on Fox 5 review
On paper, the UFC's latest Fox event offered easily the best card to date. It didn't quite live up to my lofty expectations, but it was still a good show. Part of the problem was the inclusion of Shogun and BJ Penn. This isn't to criticize the matchmaking. As I said, these were all great fights (on paper). The problem is that Shogun and Penn aren't the same fighters anymore, which makes them a gamble. There's no way of knowing how the fighters are going to show up. Is it going to be the Shogun from the Dan Henderson/Machida fights or the Shogun from the Vera fight? Because Shogun is so hit or miss, it makes it hard to judge Gustafsson's performance. Did he pick him apart because he's just better or because the underwhelming Shogun showed up? It was still an impressive performance from Gustafsson, but not as much as it could've been, if we could tell for sure that it was the good Shogun that he dominated.
Penn's case is more extreme than Shogun's. Obviously questions of his preparedness and endurance have surrounded him virtually his whole career. But as the fight was going on, I started thinking less about how those questions pertained to this fight and more about how they pertained to his career; which led me to this question: has any athlete ever achieved so much while simultaneously leaving so much on the table? He's the greatest Lightweight fighter of all-time and only the second person in UFC history to hold a title in multiple weight classes, yet it still feels like he greatly underachieved. If only he had trained with a real trainer and was in shape for every fight, he probably would have beaten GSP the first time, Hughes the second time, Edgar both times, and Fitch. Could you imagine if BJ had the stamina that Ben Henderson has? He would've been virtually unbeatable. Instead, he might be the most accomplished underachiever ever.
In my review of UFC's last Fox event, I mentioned how the UFC is in a tough place because all of their previous superstars are fading. That continued with this show, as the doors closed more and more for Shogun and Penn. However, I had also mentioned some new fighters that were becoming must-see (Jon Jones, Junior Dos Santos, Cain Velasquez, and Jose Aldo). The big positive from this event? Add Benson Henderson to that list. On the heels of his fights with Clay Guida and Frankie Edgar, Henderson put together another stellar performance on Saturday night. He's now what I would call the most entertaining "decision fighter" in the sport. He's so active and aggressive; it doesn't feel like he's just trying to outpoint his opponent or play it safe. Great showing from the champ.
In total, the show was a mixed bag. Swick-Brown was pretty good and Henderson-Diaz was great, but Shogun-Gustafsson and Penn-MacDonald felt more like two stars falling than it did two stars rising; which is a shame. Hopefully their next fights will be against more consistent fighters (like Machida and Condit, respectively), where potentially dominant performances would say more about them than it would their opponents. And thankfully there's a quick turnaround to the next Fox event, where two of the three fights (Johnson-Dodson and Pettis-Cerrone) won't be subject to "declining superstar sabotage". Should be good.
Penn's case is more extreme than Shogun's. Obviously questions of his preparedness and endurance have surrounded him virtually his whole career. But as the fight was going on, I started thinking less about how those questions pertained to this fight and more about how they pertained to his career; which led me to this question: has any athlete ever achieved so much while simultaneously leaving so much on the table? He's the greatest Lightweight fighter of all-time and only the second person in UFC history to hold a title in multiple weight classes, yet it still feels like he greatly underachieved. If only he had trained with a real trainer and was in shape for every fight, he probably would have beaten GSP the first time, Hughes the second time, Edgar both times, and Fitch. Could you imagine if BJ had the stamina that Ben Henderson has? He would've been virtually unbeatable. Instead, he might be the most accomplished underachiever ever.
In my review of UFC's last Fox event, I mentioned how the UFC is in a tough place because all of their previous superstars are fading. That continued with this show, as the doors closed more and more for Shogun and Penn. However, I had also mentioned some new fighters that were becoming must-see (Jon Jones, Junior Dos Santos, Cain Velasquez, and Jose Aldo). The big positive from this event? Add Benson Henderson to that list. On the heels of his fights with Clay Guida and Frankie Edgar, Henderson put together another stellar performance on Saturday night. He's now what I would call the most entertaining "decision fighter" in the sport. He's so active and aggressive; it doesn't feel like he's just trying to outpoint his opponent or play it safe. Great showing from the champ.
In total, the show was a mixed bag. Swick-Brown was pretty good and Henderson-Diaz was great, but Shogun-Gustafsson and Penn-MacDonald felt more like two stars falling than it did two stars rising; which is a shame. Hopefully their next fights will be against more consistent fighters (like Machida and Condit, respectively), where potentially dominant performances would say more about them than it would their opponents. And thankfully there's a quick turnaround to the next Fox event, where two of the three fights (Johnson-Dodson and Pettis-Cerrone) won't be subject to "declining superstar sabotage". Should be good.
Friday, November 30, 2012
The Case for Kaepernick
For the past week or two, the hot topic in the NFL has been the quarterback situation in San Francisco. Some think Alex Smith should start, while others think Colin Kaepernick should start. Personally, I don't think there's a wrong answer. I think the Niners would be perfectly fine with Smith starting. But with that said, here's the case for why Kapernick was the right choice.
For starters, a Niners blog post points out that "the 49ers have [had] fewer really bad plays – and more really good plays – with Kaepernick at the controls". One stat given in that blog post is that, in his two starts, Kaepernick has 10 completions of 20+ yard passes, while Alex only has 22 such completions in the eight full games he has played. This is reflected in Kapernick's 9.9 yards/attempt, compared to 8.0 yards/attempt for Smith. Here's some other stat comparisons of Smith's eight starts to Kaepernick's two:
Smith:
Completion percentage- 70.0%
Third down efficiency- 38.0%
Touchdown percentage- 6.0%
Interception percentage- 2.3%
Sack percentage- 10.0%
Kaepernick:
Completion percentage- 66.7%
Third down efficiency- 40.0%
Touchdown percentage- 6.3%
Interception percentage- 2.1%
Sack percentage- 2.0%
People think Kaepernick was chosen because he's a high-risk, high-reward player; that he can provide the big plays that Smith rarely does. The thing is, he hasn't been high-risk (so far). Smith's calling card has been ball security. Kaepernick has been just as proficient in that area, but hasn't needed to take sacks or throw shorter passes to achieve that. Smith wasn't benched just because he was injured. He was benched because Kaepernick has been able to play Smith's style and more.
Of course one could (wisely) point out that Kaepernick's stats consist of a very small sample size. It's possible that defenses eventually adjust to him and that he becomes less effective. But here's the thing, if that happens, going back to Smith is easy. It's not like Smith is going to struggle if they go right back to him in three or four weeks. But on the flip side, what if Harbaugh had gone with Smith over Kaepernick and then there was a visible dropoff from Kaepernick? The media and fan base would be clamoring for a change. And if that happened, and a change was made at that point, then going back to Smith is completely off the table. Right now, Smith isn't benched because he was playing bad; he's benched because Kaepernick happens to be playing better. If you went back to Smith and then benched him, it would actually be an indictment of his play. And that you can't come back from. You can go from Kaepernick to Smith. But if you went from Smith to Kaepernick, you can't go back to Smith. In that instance, you're stuck with Kaepernick and would have to hope he really is good enough to win in the playoffs.
Which is better: going with Kaepernick and having Smith as the safety net or going with Smith and having Kaepernick as the safety net? Harbaugh didn't just go with the option that had the biggest upside, he went with the one that also had the safest plan B.
For starters, a Niners blog post points out that "the 49ers have [had] fewer really bad plays – and more really good plays – with Kaepernick at the controls". One stat given in that blog post is that, in his two starts, Kaepernick has 10 completions of 20+ yard passes, while Alex only has 22 such completions in the eight full games he has played. This is reflected in Kapernick's 9.9 yards/attempt, compared to 8.0 yards/attempt for Smith. Here's some other stat comparisons of Smith's eight starts to Kaepernick's two:
Smith:
Completion percentage- 70.0%
Third down efficiency- 38.0%
Touchdown percentage- 6.0%
Interception percentage- 2.3%
Sack percentage- 10.0%
Kaepernick:
Completion percentage- 66.7%
Third down efficiency- 40.0%
Touchdown percentage- 6.3%
Interception percentage- 2.1%
Sack percentage- 2.0%
People think Kaepernick was chosen because he's a high-risk, high-reward player; that he can provide the big plays that Smith rarely does. The thing is, he hasn't been high-risk (so far). Smith's calling card has been ball security. Kaepernick has been just as proficient in that area, but hasn't needed to take sacks or throw shorter passes to achieve that. Smith wasn't benched just because he was injured. He was benched because Kaepernick has been able to play Smith's style and more.
Of course one could (wisely) point out that Kaepernick's stats consist of a very small sample size. It's possible that defenses eventually adjust to him and that he becomes less effective. But here's the thing, if that happens, going back to Smith is easy. It's not like Smith is going to struggle if they go right back to him in three or four weeks. But on the flip side, what if Harbaugh had gone with Smith over Kaepernick and then there was a visible dropoff from Kaepernick? The media and fan base would be clamoring for a change. And if that happened, and a change was made at that point, then going back to Smith is completely off the table. Right now, Smith isn't benched because he was playing bad; he's benched because Kaepernick happens to be playing better. If you went back to Smith and then benched him, it would actually be an indictment of his play. And that you can't come back from. You can go from Kaepernick to Smith. But if you went from Smith to Kaepernick, you can't go back to Smith. In that instance, you're stuck with Kaepernick and would have to hope he really is good enough to win in the playoffs.
Which is better: going with Kaepernick and having Smith as the safety net or going with Smith and having Kaepernick as the safety net? Harbaugh didn't just go with the option that had the biggest upside, he went with the one that also had the safest plan B.
Saturday, November 3, 2012
Fool's Gold
The Gold Glove winners were announced this week. The big headline was Mike Trout losing to Adam Jones. To see how questionable of a choice that was, I decided to look up some stats (Defensive Runs Saved, Ultimate Zone Rating, Fielding Percentage, Range Factor, and Defensive Wins Above Replacement) and compare the two. Here's what I found:
Trout had such a big statistical advantage it's laughable. The one knock I read against Trout came from a comment on an ESPN article, which brought up Trout shifting to LF when they would bring in Peter Bourjos for defensive purposes. The problem with that point is that it doesn't take into account how good Bourjos is defensively. Being not as good as Bourjos automatically means he's not as good as Jones? That would be like saying Jordan wasn't as good of a defender as Dumars, because he wasn't the best defensive player on his team. You wouldn't fault Jordan for playing with Pippen, so why would you fault Trout for playing with Bourjos (who, by the way, did have the highest UZR of anyone with a minimum of 500 innings played)?
Even if you held that against Trout, that doesn't mean Jones was the right choice. Denard Span had 20 DRS, an 8.5 UZR, a .989 FPCT, a .289 RF, and 2.4 dWAR. Not only did Jones have the lowest DRS of any qualified center fielder and negative defensive wins, he also committed the most errors. Yes, he had 439 putouts, but he still only had 54.9 putouts per error. By comparison, Trout had 132 putouts per error and Span had 84.8. So regardless of whether you thought it should or shouldn't go to Trout, it clearly shouldn't have gone to Jones. Here are some other questionable choices:
Carlos Gonzalez over Martin Prado:
Chase Headley over David Wright:
Jimmy Rollins over Clint Barmes:
Finally, the biggest travesty of all, Andrew McCutchen over Michael Bourn:
McCutchen over Bourn? Bourn is statistically the best defensive outfielder in baseball. How did he lose to someone with subpar stats? Even if you don't think advanced metrics are 100% conclusive, you can't ignore significant gaps. If Bourn had 24 DRS and McCutchen had 19, you might be able to make an argument that stats don't tell a complete story. But a 29-run difference? That's hard to write-off. All of these questionable decisions involved at least a 19-run difference. Is it really reasonable to expect a margin of error of 20? These players chosen were questionable at best and preposterous at worst. I hope these perplexing Gold Glove selections don't carry over to the AL MVP, and that the rightful winner prevails.
DRS
|
UZR
|
FPCT
|
RF
|
dWAR
|
|
Jones
|
-16
|
-6.7
|
.982
|
2.75
|
-1.3
|
Trout
|
23
|
10.6
|
.993
|
2.70
|
2.2
|
Trout had such a big statistical advantage it's laughable. The one knock I read against Trout came from a comment on an ESPN article, which brought up Trout shifting to LF when they would bring in Peter Bourjos for defensive purposes. The problem with that point is that it doesn't take into account how good Bourjos is defensively. Being not as good as Bourjos automatically means he's not as good as Jones? That would be like saying Jordan wasn't as good of a defender as Dumars, because he wasn't the best defensive player on his team. You wouldn't fault Jordan for playing with Pippen, so why would you fault Trout for playing with Bourjos (who, by the way, did have the highest UZR of anyone with a minimum of 500 innings played)?
Even if you held that against Trout, that doesn't mean Jones was the right choice. Denard Span had 20 DRS, an 8.5 UZR, a .989 FPCT, a .289 RF, and 2.4 dWAR. Not only did Jones have the lowest DRS of any qualified center fielder and negative defensive wins, he also committed the most errors. Yes, he had 439 putouts, but he still only had 54.9 putouts per error. By comparison, Trout had 132 putouts per error and Span had 84.8. So regardless of whether you thought it should or shouldn't go to Trout, it clearly shouldn't have gone to Jones. Here are some other questionable choices:
Carlos Gonzalez over Martin Prado:
DRS
|
UZR
|
FPCT
|
RF
|
dWAR
|
|
Gonzalez
|
-13
|
-8.5
|
.982
|
1.71
|
-1.9
|
Prado
|
12
|
10.7
|
.984
|
1.72
|
1.7
|
Chase Headley over David Wright:
DRS
|
UZR
|
FPCT
|
RF
|
dWAR
|
|
Headley
|
-3
|
6.0
|
.976
|
2.67
|
0
|
Wright
|
16
|
15.4
|
.974
|
2.50
|
2.1
|
Jimmy Rollins over Clint Barmes:
DRS
|
UZR
|
FPCT
|
RF
|
dWAR
|
|
Rollins
|
-8
|
4.4
|
.978
|
3.83
|
0
|
Barmes
|
13
|
14.4
|
.972
|
4.24
|
2.1
|
Finally, the biggest travesty of all, Andrew McCutchen over Michael Bourn:
DRS
|
UZR
|
FPCT
|
RF
|
dWAR
|
|
McCutchen
|
-5
|
-6.9
|
.997
|
2.44
|
-0.2
|
Bourn
|
24
|
22.4
|
.995
|
2.59
|
3.0
|
McCutchen over Bourn? Bourn is statistically the best defensive outfielder in baseball. How did he lose to someone with subpar stats? Even if you don't think advanced metrics are 100% conclusive, you can't ignore significant gaps. If Bourn had 24 DRS and McCutchen had 19, you might be able to make an argument that stats don't tell a complete story. But a 29-run difference? That's hard to write-off. All of these questionable decisions involved at least a 19-run difference. Is it really reasonable to expect a margin of error of 20? These players chosen were questionable at best and preposterous at worst. I hope these perplexing Gold Glove selections don't carry over to the AL MVP, and that the rightful winner prevails.
Sunday, October 14, 2012
The Best D in the League?
Who has the best defense the NFL? Some say Houston. Some say Chicago. Some say Seattle. How could anyone say anything but San Francisco? Let's compare their rankings:
Houston- 4th fewest points, 3rd fewest yards
Chicago- 3rd fewest points, 5th fewest yards
Seattle- 2nd fewest points, fewest yards
San Francisco- Fewest points, 2nd fewest yards
Those are pretty close, but what about the competition they have faced? Here's the rankings of the offenses that each has faced:
Houston- 19.8 ppg, 320.3 ypg
Chicago-18.7 ppg, 321 ypg
Seattle- 19 ppg, 299.9 ypg
San Francisco- 22.9 ppg, 345.9 ypg
Some would say that points per game and yards per game aren't extensive enough. Using advanced stats, Football Outsiders ranks the defenses as follows: Chicago, Houston, Seattle, San Francisco. The crazy part? Here's Football Oustiders' average ranking of each of their opponents:
Houston- 23.8
Chicago- 19.6
Seattle- 20.2
San Francisco- 16.6
By Football Outsiders' own rankings, the Niners have faced the best offenses. The Niners have given up the fewest points in the league, to better offenses than Houston, Chicago, or Seattle faced, and they're not the best defense in the league? How does that make any sense? I'm sorry, but San Francisco has the best defense in the league.
Houston- 4th fewest points, 3rd fewest yards
Chicago- 3rd fewest points, 5th fewest yards
Seattle- 2nd fewest points, fewest yards
San Francisco- Fewest points, 2nd fewest yards
Those are pretty close, but what about the competition they have faced? Here's the rankings of the offenses that each has faced:
Houston- 19.8 ppg, 320.3 ypg
Chicago-18.7 ppg, 321 ypg
Seattle- 19 ppg, 299.9 ypg
San Francisco- 22.9 ppg, 345.9 ypg
Some would say that points per game and yards per game aren't extensive enough. Using advanced stats, Football Outsiders ranks the defenses as follows: Chicago, Houston, Seattle, San Francisco. The crazy part? Here's Football Oustiders' average ranking of each of their opponents:
Houston- 23.8
Chicago- 19.6
Seattle- 20.2
San Francisco- 16.6
By Football Outsiders' own rankings, the Niners have faced the best offenses. The Niners have given up the fewest points in the league, to better offenses than Houston, Chicago, or Seattle faced, and they're not the best defense in the league? How does that make any sense? I'm sorry, but San Francisco has the best defense in the league.
Saturday, October 13, 2012
New Rule is not a Flop
Starting this season, the NBA will finally penalize flopping. Surprisingly, this new rule wasn't met with universal praise and, quite frankly, I'm dumbfounded by that. Jalen Rose tweeted, "I appreciate rules against 'FLOPPING' but dislike the new penalties. Any
punishment should happen DURING the game(personal/tech foul)." In his article on Grantland, Zach Lowe stated, "An in-game punishment would be ideal, especially in the rare case in
which a blatant flop tricks the referee. It wouldn’t take long for a
video-review official to make the call, and the victimized team would
shoot a technical after a timeout, minimizing the interruption."
In-game punishments? As Zach stated, the way for this to be done would be to review it. People complain about the pace of sports already; I don't think reviewing more plays is going to help that. How would this even be done fairly, without reviewing every flop? Do we really want/expect the refs to review every flop? The only thing worse then flopping would be flops leading to delays in the game.
Flops like these:
Flopping to exaggerate the contact of actual fouls is one thing. The complete fabrication that a foul happened is what needs to be punished. This may sound strict, but I think the flops in those videos should be punished with suspensions. Why? Because they NEVER need to happen. Pretending like you were fouled, when you weren't, is a disgrace to the game. The problem isn't the fines. It's that the fines even need to exist in the first place.
In-game punishments? As Zach stated, the way for this to be done would be to review it. People complain about the pace of sports already; I don't think reviewing more plays is going to help that. How would this even be done fairly, without reviewing every flop? Do we really want/expect the refs to review every flop? The only thing worse then flopping would be flops leading to delays in the game.
Jalen also tweeted why he doesn't like the punishment: "You must get 16 technical fouls to pay $5k while the 2nd flop has the same fee attached? Don't like it." I think that punishment is completely fair. Here's why: technical fouls are incidental; flopping is not. Technical fouls can happen in the heat of the moment. Flopping is an intentional attempt to deceive the referees. In fact, I even think that $5,000 dollars is low, for the type of flopping the refs should penalize.
Flops like these:
Flopping to exaggerate the contact of actual fouls is one thing. The complete fabrication that a foul happened is what needs to be punished. This may sound strict, but I think the flops in those videos should be punished with suspensions. Why? Because they NEVER need to happen. Pretending like you were fouled, when you weren't, is a disgrace to the game. The problem isn't the fines. It's that the fines even need to exist in the first place.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)